Christian charity volunteer wins £13,000 settlement after wrongful arrest for silent prayer outside Birmingham abortion clinic

Isabel Vaughan-Spruce, a volunteer for a Christian charity, recently won a £13,000 settlement and an apology from West Midlands Police after being wrongfully arrested for silently praying outside an abortion clinic. Her case has drawn significant attention, particularly as it raises concerns about the boundaries of free speech and thought in the UK.

Arrests and Legal Claims

Vaughan-Spruce was first arrested in November 2022 for praying silently within a “buffer zone” outside the BPAS Robert Clinic in Kings Norton, Birmingham. This area had been designated to prevent protests and protect the public from potential intimidation. Despite being found not guilty by Birmingham Magistrates Court, she was arrested again in February 2023 for the same action—praying silently in the same location. During her second arrest, police officers told her that “engaging in prayer” was the offense, even though she insisted she was not protesting.

Compensation and Apology

Following these incidents, Vaughan-Spruce, who is also the director of the anti-abortion group March for Life UK, pursued legal action against West Midlands Police. Her claims included wrongful arrest, false imprisonment, assault, and a breach of her human rights. The police eventually dropped their investigation and issued an apology, along with the £13,000 payout.

A Growing Concern

The case has ignited a broader debate about the potential criminalization of silent prayer outside abortion clinics, a move reportedly being considered by the UK government. Lord Frost, a former Conservative cabinet minister, voiced his concerns, stating that the arrest of Vaughan-Spruce represented a threat not just to freedom of speech but also to freedom of thought. He warned that if the government proceeds with formal legislation to criminalize such actions, it could set a dangerous precedent.

Silent Prayer and Freedom of Thought

Vaughan-Spruce has been vocal about her belief that “silent prayer is not a crime,” emphasizing that no one should be arrested for the thoughts they hold in their minds. She expressed gratitude for the legal support she received from ADF UK and highlighted her concern that similar violations could occur elsewhere if current trends continue. Vaughan-Spruce sees her case as part of a larger cultural shift toward suppressing viewpoint diversity, particularly Christian thought and prayer.

Wider Implications

Lord Michael Farmer, a former treasurer of the Conservative Party, echoed these sentiments, describing Vaughan-Spruce’s arrest as a “travesty of justice.” He argued that the case exemplifies an “undemocratic clampdown” on Christian expression in the UK, which could intensify as “buffer zones” are implemented nationwide. Farmer warned that if pro-life thought is prosecutable today, other forms of thought could face similar censorship tomorrow.

Police Response

West Midlands Police addressed the situation, explaining that the Public Space Protection Order (PSPO) was introduced by Birmingham City Council in 2022 in response to complaints from residents about protester intimidation. Although they settled Vaughan-Spruce’s claim without admitting liability, the police emphasized their ongoing efforts to work with the council and consider feedback from the local community.

TDPel Media

This article was published on TDPel Media. Thanks for reading!

Share on Facebook «||» Share on Twitter «||» Share on Reddit «||» Share on LinkedIn